You can compare it to other markers of the same generation: SFT shocker, 2k5 timmies, DM5, Quest, etc. As far as actually trading it for any comparable markers, you will have to do some work. People associate ICD with broken because most people have no idea how to work ICD gear. As Stewie said, you have to be able to balance the regulators and do regular maintenance.
Virtue did not make ICD boards. Possible boards are Chaos, Nox, Kila, Predator (lite or Full code)