[4leaf4life]

Originally Posted by Kidd88

I agree. I've seen three different answers now in three different posts. I also can not find anywhere in the rules that says it's not allowed in any certain division. Can some one point out where this is covered in the rule book?

Originally Posted by Kidd88

All the book says is that a coach is alowed in a desiganated area on the lines for Race to 5/6/7. It says nothing about players in staging or people off field helping players on the field durring a point.

The rule book on the MWXL site is from 2010. We do all know the new rules are out for 2011 and some things have changed.

Now for coaching for R/2 D4 5 man. In the past we have aloud and then not aloud coaching. Myself and a few others will be meeting this weekend to discuss what will be aloud.

I would like people express how they feel, either coaching or no coaching.

THIS DOES NOT NEED TO BE AN ARGUMENT
Just a simple coaching or no coaching will do.

If you feel the need to express yourself more PM me

Nick

[Lucky-Luxe]

No coaching

[gruesomekyle]

Coaching- Snake side only.

[Barber]

Why not follow PSP rules as closely as possible? That would make the most sense to me. Allow the snake side coaching.

[Ralo]

No coaching for D4 race to 2
Snake Side for D3 race to 4

[bneally]

no coaching

[4leaf4life]

Originally Posted by Barber

Why not follow PSP rules as closely as possible? That would make the most sense to me. Allow the snake side coaching.

I understand what your saying. That is going to be the main point at keeping coaching. On the other hand D4, is where you have new players coming up. They need to learn the basics of the game themselves, not be told it.

[Keiser Sosei]

D4 no coaching
D3 snake side only

[jacapbinc]

Originally Posted by 4leaf4life

I understand what your saying. That is going to be the main point at keeping coaching. On the other hand D4, is where you have new players coming up. They need to learn the basics of the game themselves, not be told it.

TROOF.... NO COACHING D4!!!

[4leaf4life]

D3 will have snake side coaching just like the PSP. The only coaching question we face is in D4

[preder_10]

D3 coach d4 no coach

[FightingOriole]

D3 coach. D4 no coach

[Ralo]

Originally Posted by 4leaf4life

I understand what your saying. That is going to be the main point at keeping coaching. On the other hand D4, is where you have new players coming up. They need to learn the basics of the game themselves, not be told it.

[Moraken]

D4 no coaching

[mhohn]

D4 coaching snake side only

[smokeymcpot02]

D4 snake side coaching only

[PballJunkie19]

I agree with what Barber said, This is somewhat of a feeder league to PSP, After all the Series prize is entry to World Cup. Why not follow PSP rules that way the winning team isnt forced to change anything going into Cup.

[ybekool]

I think that coaching shouldn’t be allowed in the d4 race to 2. Although if it were allowed, i would say that it doesn’t matter which side you coach from because it’s being relayed across field anyway. By coaching the snake player, he can relay the coaching to the other players (making the long term game differ). Like the question asked, it’s COACHING OR NO COACHING-- not which side.
Steven Schellhorn
Captain of The Vicious Bunnys

[Kidd88]

Coaching per PSP rules

[jbmcduff]

D4 coaching snake side, this does feed into World Cup.

[JP#14]

Originally Posted by 4leaf4life

I understand what your saying. That is going to be the main point at keeping coaching. On the other hand D4, is where you have new players coming up. They need to learn the basics of the game themselves, not be told it.

No Coaching D4.