I've used Dye, Empire and Sly.
I went through 2 pairs of Dye in one summer of Rec play because the seams kept letting go. The Empire ones were nice except the velcro around the bicep area would literally scratch me until I bled. I'm currently using the Sly pads over all I really enjoy them, they have some nice palm padding without making the hands feel bulky, they are super light and breathable, I don't notice I'm wearing them at all which is a plus. My only issue with them was that mine had a hole in one when I received it. (Keep in mind the Sly pads I wear are the newer ones, not the ones you posted)