Originally Posted by Fat_Joe
How could you possibly think that Manning would share the MVP in 2004 when he had the greatest season any QB has ever had? Thats jusf dumb.
Tom Brady's 07-08 season was better.
Peyton Manning 2004 - 336 completions, 497 attempts for 67.6 completion percentage; 4,557 yards with 49 TDs/10 INTs with 38 rushing yards
Tom Brady 2007 - 398 completions, 578 attempts for 68.9 completion percentage; 4,806 yards with 50 TDs/8 INTs with 98 rushing yards and 2 TDs
Brady tossed the ball about 80 times more and had 3 more total TDs, 2 less INTs, and about 300 more yards.
Manning also had better weapons around him. Marvin, James, Stokley, Wayne, Clark, and Wayne compared to Moss, Welker, Stallworth, Watson, and Maroney.