New Feedback System

**Kyle** · 06-07-2007, 02:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gbw369

Okay, so I just figured out a quick and easy way to make the transition for old feedback- when you posted in a person's original feedback thread, you can just click the leave seller feedback link there, that way you don't have to find the original sale thread (since you definitely posted in their thread you can use the feedback button- even if you didn't post in their sale thread originally)- plus, you can just copy and paste your original comments into the comment box. The only hangup on this system would the time restriction- maybe that could be waived for a month or something.

Oops, oversight on my behalf. You can no longer leave feedback in the old "feedback" forum.

BunkerKing5291 · 06-07-2007, 02:56 PM

im so lost

contract killr 47 (Banned) · 06-07-2007, 02:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kyle

Oops, oversight on my behalf. You can no longer leave feedback in the old "feedback" forum.

I think he means it wont be that hard converting it all b/c you dont really need to find the sale threads, you just have to find their feedback thread (if you posted in it before it was locked) then you can just click the leave feedback button from there

ENVIOUSballa09 · 06-07-2007, 03:01 PM

so basically you can keep your old feedback to use but then all your new feedback can go to the new system so if you hae like 80 on the old and 10 on the new you have like 90+?? is that ok?

HotѕaucE · 06-07-2007, 03:01 PM

What if the deal is done through PM's?

Example: Some one posts a WTB thread and I PM them and don't reply to the thread. How does that work?

contract killr 47 (Banned) · 06-07-2007, 03:01 PM

yea, youll just have feedback in 2 places. Not that big of a deal

thefatpaintballer14 · 06-07-2007, 03:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ENVIOUSballa09

so basically you can keep your old feedback to use but then all your new feedback can go to the new system so if you hae like 80 on the old and 10 on the new you have like 90+?? is that ok?

Eh, that's whatever you want to do. I will have my feedback in my b/s/t as 69+/0- old feedback and 100% new feedback.

Quote:

Originally Posted by HotѕaucE

What if the deal is done through PM's?

Example: Some one posts a WTB thread and I PM them and don't reply to the thread. How does that work?

If the deal is done via PM's, it doesn't count.

Dunno about wtb. Haven't tried it yet.

Edit: IF YOU POST IN A WTB THREAD, IT DOES WORK! But, for it to be eligable for feedback, you MUST post in that WTB thread. Pretty sure if a mod sees that, and you didn't post in that thread, then you will get banned for FBF.

Also, if said person has a thread, and you PM him instead of posting in his thread, and you recieve said item, just post in his thread saying you bought _________ and you received it! That's posting...

contract killr 47 (Banned) · 06-07-2007, 03:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HotѕaucE

What if the deal is done through PM's?

Example: Some one posts a WTB thread and I PM them and don't reply to the thread. How does that work?

from what i understand:

If a deal is done completely through Pm's and no posts or threads, you cant leave feedback.

For your example, yea I think you could leave feedback for that.

udflyer (Banned) · 06-07-2007, 03:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kyle

Oops, oversight on my behalf. You can no longer leave feedback in the old "feedback" forum.

why would you do that, this system is bs to get people to buy the ASM so that they will be able to search and go back and find all their past deals and get the feedback

**John** · 06-07-2007, 03:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by heysueskreesto2

is ther gonna be any way in the future to move old feedback? or are we going to forever keep our locked feedback threads?

You should keep your locked one. It shows the feedback you earned before the change. If you have the time to convert it all, that's great, but it is finethe way it is too.

Quote:

Originally Posted by mike2468

Just a quick question. How can a user leave feedback for a transaction if the thread was in the NIB forum and it ran out of gold ups before they received the item?

Make sure the seller gives you feedback as soon as you paid. Then use the yellow tag to return feedback when you get the item.

Quote:

Originally Posted by contract killr 47

I think he means it wont be that hard converting it all b/c you dont really need to find the sale threads, you just have to find their feedback thread (if you posted in it before it was locked) then you can just click the leave feedback button from there

Sorry, but that won't work. You have to find the original B/S/T thread if you want to convert feedback.

Quote:

Originally Posted by ENVIOUSballa09

so basically you can keep your old feedback to use but then all your new feedback can go to the new system so if you hae like 80 on the old and 10 on the new you have like 90+?? is that ok?

Exactly! You can reference both systems now. You just can't add to the old feedback thread anymore, but you can always show it to people.

Quote:

Originally Posted by HotѕaucE

What if the deal is done through PM's?
Example: Some one posts a WTB thread and I PM them and don't reply to the thread. How does that work?

You need to reply in the thread.

Quote:

Originally Posted by contract killr 47

yea, youll just have feedback in 2 places. Not that big of a deal

Bingo.

Pattawa123 · 06-07-2007, 03:20 PM

All i can say to this... is, this is the dumbest most pointless change PBN has made. This is worse than the removal of the sidebar.

Oh well, just have to cope with the change....

Much love to the Nation

zero love to this change.

frootloops · 06-07-2007, 03:22 PM

so can we get everyone in our old feedback thread to post in this new system?

Pattawa123 · 06-07-2007, 03:24 PM

If you know the threads where you did the deal in...

**DaveEllis** · 06-07-2007, 03:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pattawa123

All i can say to this... is, this is the dumbest most pointless change PBN has made. This is worse than the removal of the sidebar.

Oh well, just have to cope with the change....

Much love to the Nation

zero love to this change.

Yes, it is dumb because it creates a system that balances out the honor system with providing links to transactions, keeps actual counts of people's feedback instead of the sometimes skewed counts people provide and strays away from the old feedback system which was an honor system that strayed.

frootloops · 06-07-2007, 03:27 PM

i read everything but i just want to make this clear.. so for people to post in this new feedback thing you have to go to the spefic thread where u bought or sold something for them to be able to post in the new system

**John** · 06-07-2007, 03:28 PM

Yes. The link should already be in your feedback if you did the deal this year.

contract killr 47 (Banned) · 06-07-2007, 03:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DaveEllis

Yes, it is dumb because it creates a system that balances out the honor system with providing links to transactions, keeps actual counts of people's feedback instead of the sometimes skewed counts people provide and strays away from the old feedback system which was an honor system that strayed.

yea how stupid to make pbn b/s/t more safe. What a retarded idea.

**TargetIndy** · 06-07-2007, 03:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by frootloops

i read everything but i just want to make this clear.. so for people to post in this new feedback thing you have to go to the spefic thread where u bought or sold something for them to be able to post in the new system

Correct.

snowmansent2hell · 06-07-2007, 03:28 PM

very nice improvement

Cabooser · 06-07-2007, 03:34 PM

So I didn't see how to convert old feedback. How do you do that?

EDIT: Nevermind, I found it, but I have feedback from a long time ago. I don;t really want to try and get all the people to leave me new feedback

**Kyle** · 06-07-2007, 03:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by udflyer

why would you do that, this system is bs to get people to buy the ASM so that they will be able to search and go back and find all their past deals and get the feedback

Once again, you are wrong. Nobody is making you move your old feedback into the new system. The old feedback will always be there for you to refer to. The new system merely replaces what was a very error prone system.

Please think before you post, your attitude in this thread is not really helping with this transition to what is a far, far superior system that should result in less fraud and better transactions for everyone.